Week 20 – Selection
There are various selection methods used by businesses in
order to select the right candidate for the job, my step dads company
Collaborate London is a company that I am particularly familiar with. I have
experienced the selection process and have been told about it by my step dad. Selection
is extremely important and has to be done properly, to be done successfully a
company will have to gather as much information about the candidates as
possible, organise and evaluate this information and compare and contrast this information
between candidates. Collaborate London is a growing business, it is only three
years old and has over 10 employees and some part time staff. Because it’s a
relatively small business every employee has to be able to perform well and do
the job assigned to them. The selection process they use is to first short list
from the information on CV’s and application forms, then carry out interviews
on the candidates that have the best suited skills for the job based on the
information from the CV’s. The final process is work simulation, the tasks the
candidates will be asked to perform on a day to day basis are explained to them
and the Collaborate interviewer overlooks them carrying out this task and
judges how well they do.
Shortlisting information from CV’s and application forms is
often most businesses first step of the selection process, it is crucial to
examine all CV’s and application forms and wean out the ones that don’t meet
the company’s expectations and shortlist the ones that stick out from the rest.
There are massive advantages of carrying out this process as it is the first step
to choosing a possible candidate.
The next step is to interview the candidates left from the
first stage of the selection process. There are many advantages and
disadvantages of interviewing. These are –
Advantages:
The interviewer can obtain detailed information about the
candidate, including feelings towards the company, perceptions and opinions.
Detailed questions can be asked to clarify ambiguities and pressing on for full
answers and following up on incomplete answers. Questions can be created by the
interviewer to suit each candidate, blank spots on the cv or application form
can be filled in. Face to face interviews mean that the interviewer can observe
the candidates facial expressions and body language which will give the
interviewer an indication of the candidate’s honest feelings.
Disadvantages:
Interviews give only the interviewer the chance to assess
the candidate, other employees at the company may prefer other candidates, but
it’s only the choice of one employee of the company to make the choice. So no
other members of the company have a say in which candidate they think is the
best suited to the role. Some possible candidates may not excel in one to one
situations, shyer candidates may not put their skills and experience forward,
and although they might perform best at the job required of them, they might
find it hard to convince the interviewer.
Interviews are also very time consuming, and time costs money. The
interviewer will have to put aside projects and work that they are currently
working on to interview potential candidates.
Work simulations, realistic job simulations is the last part
of the selection process that Collaborate use. The advantages of this process
are that if two or three possible candidates from the interview process it can
help a company to decide. Putting the remaining candidates into realistic job
simulations is the best way to separate the candidates, if one of the
candidates excels and completes the task well before the others then it can be
clear that he or she is the person to hire. A disadvantage of this could be
that the candidates could crumble under the pressure, a pressure that on a
normal day to day basis at work they wouldn’t be under, so it can be a bit
biased if one of the candidates struggles under pressure.
During my A-levels at sixth form I entered an extra-curricular
activity called business enterprise, in which business studies students were
given the opportunity to create a product and sell it at various craft fairs.
In order to get into the project each student had to go through an interview to
be selected. As the project was over-subscribed there was no guaranteed place
for any of the students. During the interview I was asked various questions
regarding my interest in the subject and why I felt I would be good for the
project. I felt the interview was particularly effective, the interviewer had a
good set of questions lined up regarding the project and I felt comfortable whilst
in the interview.
As the blog said earlier I am familiar with Collaborates
selection process, although I feel it is a good process there are one or two
areas which could be improved. One of which, during the interview process more
employees could get involved with the interviewing, although it would take up
time and the employees would have to put their current work and projects on
hold, it would be a worthwhile process so that all employees, or at least the
management and higher level employees can make a decision together.
Conclusion – This blog has looked mainly at Collaborates
selection process, and through looking at it and analysing it I have learnt
that the process is good, the business is going well which is also a sign that
the process is working. The blog has looked at different types of selection and
which processes are good.